Behind the Agenda: Creativity & Legitimacy in the AI Era

12 Aug 2025

Behind the Agenda: Creativity & Legitimacy in the AI Era

AI doesn’t just change how creative work is done - it changes the criteria by which creative value is judged. This piece explores how that shift is redefining success in the media economy, drawing on one of the shortlisted technical papers and sessions focused on tool adoption, creative integrity, and competitive edge.

This year’s IBC Conference spans a wide set of themes - from AI and creative workflows to trust, disinformation, and the evolving conditions for long-term differentiation. One shortlisted technical paper offers a particularly sharp lens on how these topics connect.

Too often, the industry debate around AI and creativity stops at the process level, framing AI as either an enabler or a threat. This framing helps identify operational conditions for success, but it misses the deeper shift underway. AI is not only reshaping how creative work is made - through efficiency gains, streamlined workflows, and new ideation tools - it is altering the very criteria by which creativity is judged. In that shift, trust and legitimacy become inseparable from creative value, and decisive in determining who survives in the new media economy.

Creativity has always been one of the media industry’s most resilient differentiators, withstanding shifts in platforms and audience habits. Audience fragmentation makes this resilience easier to see. While viewing has moved away from traditional PSBs toward on-demand services, broadcasters still held the top three positions and half of the UK’s ten most-watched titles in 2024. Gavin & Stacey: The Finale drew 18.6 million viewers, alongside Mr Bates vs The Post Office. Different in style but alike in impact, both created singular, unmissable moments that cut through format divides.

Distinctiveness - the ability to produce something that feels unique and irreplaceable - is widely recognised as a hallmark of creativity. It sits alongside novelty and value as its other cardinal features. Subscription audiences often articulate their preferences in these terms. Ofcom’s 2025 report found that 36% of Netflix subscribers cited “content not available elsewhere” and 35% cited “something different to broadcast TV” as reasons for subscribing. For Disney+, 34% named exclusivity.

The same pattern shows up in satisfaction scores: Netflix enjoys an 80% satisfaction rate compared with 68% for UK PSBs. While PSB engagement is strongly tied to cultural identity and variety, audiences have voiced a desire for greater creative risk-taking. The implication: creativity, expressed through distinctiveness and novelty, remains a core driver of competitive advantage.

It’s no surprise, then, that the industry has looked to AI and analytics to enhance creative work. Research shows that creativity and analytics together outperform either in isolation. FOX’s 2025 Super Bowl coverage is a recent example: partnering with Tubi brought an additional 13.6 million viewers and fresh audience insights, proving that data can amplify creative impact when used in service of distinctive content.

But process-level optimisation, however effective, won’t guarantee resilience for long. Tool parity arrives quickly. When it does, advantage will shift away from who uses AI best to who can define - and defend - what counts as creativity in a way audiences trust.

That’s where the shortlisted IBC2025 technical paper offers a different view. It argues that “generative AI moves from information-processing to meaning-making,” with humans and machines now sharing the doing of creative work. This blurs boundaries of authorship and skill, forcing creative fields to renegotiate the tacit norms and moral orders - the “social imaginary” - that underpin legitimate creative work.

In this light, creative value is not fixed in the work itself; it emerges through interpretation, shaped by originality, authorship, transparency, and cultural resonance. When an AI-generated photograph won a major art competition in 2024, it was celebrated - until its origins were revealed. The image hadn’t changed, but its perceived legitimacy had.

As production norms shift, so do the terms on which creativity is recognised. Originality and distinctiveness still matter, but in an AI-saturated environment, the process - and the trust it earns - becomes a determining factor in perceived worth.

Broadcasters like ITV already show what this looks like in practice. In its 2025 results, ITV credited growth in both digital ad revenue and audience share to “high-quality, trusted content.” This pairing of distinctive creative output with a clear, consistently upheld value framework demonstrates how creativity, when underpinned by legitimacy, can deliver sustainable competitive advantage.

Trust, then, is not just a desirable attribute. It is integral to creativity’s ability to function as a differentiator. In the AI-driven media landscape, creative success depends on legitimacy to be recognised as such. The organisations most likely to thrive will be those that can articulate their definition of creativity with precision - and defend it, visibly and consistently.

IBC2025 will explore these dynamics in depth. AI, creativity, and trust will be discussed as interconnected forces shaping the next era of media. Delegates will hear from leaders who are not just using AI to work faster or cheaper, but redefining what audiences consider truly creative - and why they trust it.

Must see sessions will be:

AI in Post-Production -Timothy Last, Hogarth (WPP) & Willy Lamm, SWR
13 Sep 2025 | 11:30 – 12:30 | Technical Papers Room
New research into how creative professionals navigate AI’s influence on legitimacy, value, and authorship in production workflows.

Netflix: Empowering Creativity Through Innovation - Victor Marti, Netflix & Migue Amoedo, Vancouver Media
13 Sep 2025 | 10:00 – 10:40 | Conference Room 1
Behind-the-scenes insights into how production innovation empowers storytellers to tell their best stories.

MovieLabs: Leading the Vision - Richard Berger (MovieLabs), Eddie Drake (Disney), James Crossland (Warner Bros. Discovery), Phil Wiser (Paramount), Yoshikazu Takashima (Sony Pictures)
13 Sep 2025 | 12:45 – 13:15 | Conference Room 1
A look at progress towards the MovieLabs 2030 Vision for next-generation media creation.

Fighting Disinformation and Disengagement: Staying Relevant in the Digital Age - Antonia Kerle (BBC), Emily Shelley (PA Media Group), Laura Rhea (Ofcom), Maxime Carboni (Euronews), Raed Fakih (Al Jazeera)
13 Sep 2025 | 14:15 – 15:00 | Conference Room 1
How news providers and broadcasters can maintain trust and accuracy in the face of disinformation.

Media 2025: Winners and Losers in the New Content Ecosystem - Thomas Gruber (ProSiebenSat.1), Jens Richter (Fremantle)
14 Sep 2025 | 10:15 – 11:15 | Conference Room 1
Strategies for thriving in a post-peak TV market, from AI-driven production to content that resonates across platforms.

View all Blogposts
Loading